Hello! @caschmidt
Welcome to the LastPass Community.
In case the browser extension is not saving your settings, I will recommend you clean your internet browser (cookies and cache), log in to your LastPass account again, and set the vault view to your preferences.
In case you are still getting the same scenario, please remove the LastPass extension from your internet browser, and in case you have any other extension installed, please try to turn them off. Once that is done, clean your internet browser again, reinstall the LastPass extension, and try again.
Please let me know if you need additional help.
Greetings!
Verlaine | Customer Care